Mindconnection's Electrical Connection: Grounding system case history

This case history is about a grounding system I installed. A woman asked me about her whole house surge protector ("Meter Treater"). I read the contract's fine print, which basically exempted the installer (the utility) from any liability or warranty claims whatsoever.

About the author:

I'm not just an MBA--I'm also an electrical engineer and a Master Electrician.
I write columns for national electrical trade magazines and electrical Web sites.
Companies like 3M and Merrill Lynch call me to ask for technical advice.
I'm a Senior Member of the IEEE (Institute of Electronic and Electrical Engineers) and have held several officerships (including Chair) of the Kansas City Section (named Outstanding Section five years in a row).
I designed the lightning protection system now used on all U.S. commercial air traffic control towers.

Perhaps you'll agree I have some credentials for what comes next.

Click on the thumbnails to see the images full-sized.

The catch was the home had to comply with the National Electrical Code, and very, very few homes ever do (mine does, but did not when I bought it).

I fixed one severe violation of Article 250 (her water pipes weren't bonded to the electrical system--she lives in a duplex and her system was bonded to her neighbor's pipes and the two systems weren't bonded together). I then installed a very fine supplemental grounding system, using buried #4 wire and driven rods.

OK, I know your eyes are probably glazing over at this point, but bear with me.

Her home sits between two trees. In a recent lightning storm, these trees were hit badly (as the photos show). One tree got so hot at the point of the lightning strike that the leaves were instantly desiccated. This, and other evidence, shows she had a huge electrical field present at the back of her home.

In the photos, you can see where an electrical charge blackened the outer surfaces of the grounding electrode conductor and the top of one ground rod. You can also see where energy discolored gravel.

On the other side of the fence, her hot tub was destroyed. Inside the house, nothing was damaged, as the Meter Treater was able to shunt the electrical surge to ground.

If not for this grounding system, her house may well have burned down. Yet, I installed this system for about $30 in parts. If you have not hired an electrician to beef up your home's grounding system, I urge you to do so. It's a cheap insurance policy.

If you are an electrician, follow the National Electrical Code, Article 250, to the letter. Get a copy of IEEE-142, and read it carefully.

Click photo

Photo 1: North tree. Notice the damage from the lightning blast. This part of the tree is sitting directly on power lines.

Click photo

Photo 2: North tree. A little closer up. The heat was so intense, it dessicated the leaves near the point of the blast. The leaves are still green about 12 feet from the blast.

Click photo

Photo 3: North tree. Here, you can see how massive the damage was. Remember, this is only one of the trees that got hit. Look at how large it is, compared to the fence.

The tree is lying on top of power lines. Notice how green it is from this view. That's because you're not seeing the blast zone. This was a healthy tree that got split by lightning and nearly caught fire. If not for the heavy rain, it probably would have ignited. The rain, during this storm, was so heavy that visibility was often as little as three feet.	Click photo Photo 4. North tree
OK, you get a break from looking at the same tree. Here, you can see the north tree to the left, and you can see the south tree to the right. The point of this photo is to show you the south end of the lightning zone. Look how large of an area the electric field covered! Her electric service entrance is almost mid-center of the East-West axis. This south tree also had significant damage.	Click photo Photo 5. South tree
Now we get to the meat of the thing. If you look closely, you can see black marks on the #4 conductor. It is buried in gravel and sand, and sat in water during this storm. The part that sticks up had a higher resistance to earth than the buried part, so it wasn't able to discharge to earth. Notice the top of the electrode--black!	Click photo Photo 6. Electrode
Here's another photo of that electrode. In both of this photo and the one above, you can see discoloration in the formerly white gravel leading to the fence. The hot tub on the other side was fried. You can see some vegetation got zapped, too. These photos were all taken a few days after the storm. Oddly, the gravel under the fence has some of the color of the fence now--you can see how current flow under the fence damaged the fence. We think it vaporized paint and impregnated the particles into the rock. The rock was added after the fence was painted, so this isn't from overpaint.	Click photo Photo 7. Electrode

What's the moral of this story? Well, here are the principles it demonstrates:

Electricity does not follow the path of least resistance. It takes all available paths, following Kirchoff's Law (parallel circuits) and Ohm's Law (series circuits).
Electricity can jump into and out of a grounding rod.
A good grounding system can shunt huge amounts of energy away from your electrical system.
Electricity travels through water that is sitting in gravel, taking any path it can get to return to the source. It won't necessarily flow directly into one of the ground rods.

For more information on grounding and the National Electrical Code, visit http://www.mikeholt.com. Mike is an internationally recognized expert on grounding and bonding. Mike first saw these photos while we were traveling together on a Delta flight from Orlando to Kansas City.
There is nothing that can absolutely protect you against lightning. The Heary Brothers have a grossly overpriced system that they claim overcomes the laws of physics clearly shown here. It doesn't work. However, a good Franklin Rod system for lightning protection will provide a high degree of protection--far more than you'd get with no system at all. And that could save your life. I know lightning protection experts all over the U.S., and I have to give my personal recommendation to Mark Harger--you can find him at http://www.harger.com. He's not paying for an ad, here--he's just the best there is, and he gets the recommendation.

Electrical Connection: Grounding case history

Lightning protection Websites

Electrical Resources

Books

Courses and Training

Miscellaneous