| Review
of
The On-Demand Brand, by Rick Mathieson (Hardcover, 2010)
(You can print this review in landscape mode, if you
want a hardcopy)
Reviewer:
Mark Lamendola, author of over 6,000 articles.
This book is 259 pages long, and consists of 10 chapters. Each
chapter addresses one rule of media buying or advertising
strategization.
This book isn't a marketing text. There's no number
crunching and there aren't any product development research case
studies. The book focuses advertising rather than on marketing. The
subtitle is reflective of the book's contents, only if you change
"marketing" to "advertising." The two are related, but not the same.
This book's target audience is the media buyer or advertising
director of a corporation that's large enough to run television ads.
Many of the references were to television shows, television ads,
television celebrities, and television culture. As I don't watch
television, I sometimes had no clue who or what the author was talking
about. However, even without an understanding of the specific examples,
I was able to understand some important points the author made.
The author helps dispel some of the "great ideas" that have cost
companies fortunes in wasted resources. The waste is often due to poor
execution of a flawed strategy. Many companies just plain get off track,
wasting their ad budget on "marketing" efforts that were undertaken
without a clear purpose in mind. If you work in advertising at a major
corporation, you may very well save a few dozen jobs there by helping
your company invest in high ROI advertising instead of just wasting ad
budget dollars on someone's idea of "we need to....". This book will
help you gain insights toward achieving that.
I think the basic premise of this book is that if you are a media
buyer or advertising strategist, you need to look at each medium as a
separate advertising space with its own rules. And once you do that, you
won't make the mistake of trying to replicate essentially the same ad on
each medium. In fact, the advertising opportunities offered by mobile
devices (which the book addresses extensively) have such starkly
different characteristics from those of other media that you need to
strategize your mobile campaign from scratch. There is little, if any,
crossover, with other media
Unfortunately, most companies "doing digital" are treating the
various media as similar and just "repurposing" ad content from one
medium to another. This results in colossal wastes of money and
advertising opportunities.
I normally disparage a book that doesn't include a stout bibliography
as evidence it was well-researched. This book doesn't need a
bibliography as proof it was well-researched. It taps primary sources
(in researcher parlance, a primary source is the best possible source),
placing their interviews directly into the text. In fact, you'll see
entire chapters consist almost exclusively of an interview with an
expert.
So, this book isn't some rubber chicken circuit person's "book me for
your next event" promo fluff piece. It's really an advertising industry
expert providing insights of various experts who are getting results in
the real world. |